Forbidden Fruit Sex Story. How I fell in love with my girlfriend’s best friend.

Written by Zac for kinkysexstories.org

The forbidden fruit is forbidden for a reason, however sometimes the consequence is worth the taste.

This is a true story that recently happened to me. First I want to say that I am a nice guy and love and appreciate women the best I can. They are a continuous mystery and I love almost everything about them. I have gone for long periods of time without a girlfriend and have been very lonely during those times. I’m by no means a Casanova. Just a humble nice guy who does what he can to please the woman, or in this case, the women, who take an interest in me.

I have lived in San Francisco for the last 3 years now and the first 2 were very lonely. No woman wanted anything to do with me. But finally, I met Suz. She is a drop dead gorgeous brunette with long shiny hair and the most delicate of facial features. She is 5 foot 5 and has very large breasts, a small waist, and is in fantastic shape. She also wears glasses which drives me nutz. I met her at an art showing in my neighborhood and was so taken, I smiled at her, and then directly walked up to her and began talking. I am basically a very shy man, but her beauty transformed me into a different person. I was hit by lightening.

As luck would have it, we hit it off and were inseparable for months spending all our free time together. Sex took a little while to get perfect but we got there eventually and enjoyed a wonderful sex life making love about once a day. Suz was fantastic, she treated me well, and I quickly fell in love. It was a wonderful relationship and perhaps the best one I had been in. I was beginning to think about marriage.

Until I met my girlfriend’s best friend. Anna and Suz had been friends for several years and were very close. They told each other everything and before I even met Anna, I knew how important she was to Suz.

free sex stories kinky sexstories

One day I was hanging out with Suz at her apartment and Anna showed up after just working out at the gym. She was wearing spandex pants and a short tank top tee. When she walked in the door, I almost choked on her beauty. She was 5 foot 8, long blond hair, about a C cup, and an ass that did not stop. Her legs and ass were entirely too much.

I opened my mouth and said Hello, but on the inside I was completely bowled over. I fell in love with her instantly but knew I had to maintain composure. Her reaction was difficult to read. When she first saw me, she stopped and froze and starred at me, similar to my reaction. She stopped in mid sentence fro what seemed like a little too long. I don’t think Suz thought anything about it. My guess is that we both hid it enough.

Suz and Anna enjoyed having an afternoon coffee break with each other as much as possible. At the end of each day, Suz would tell me all about Anna and her life and I took an interest in it and enjoyed hearing about her. Her last boyfriend cheated on her and they broke up about 6 months ago. She was having a difficult time finding someone and had a little anger towards men. I was really surprised because she was by far the most beautiful and downright sexy girl I had every met. But I never told my girlfriend that. In fact, in order to conceal my crush on my girlfriend’s best friend, I pretended like I didn’t like Anna very much, explaining I thought she was a little bitchy and not my type, but tolerated being around her and hearing about her because she was so special to my girlfriend.

This tactic worked well because soon, Suz began to feel so comfortable about us being together that she would sometimes ask me to meet Anna somewhere because Suz was running late or couldn’t show.

One time, my girlfriend asked me to drop Anna off at the airport without her. I must confess that I was extremely excited to get the chance to be alone with Anna. I was shaking on the inside when I knocked on her apartment door but tried to keep my composure.

When Anna opened the door, she gave me a big hug and a kiss on the cheek and thanked me for taking the time to pick her up. I melted. I grabbed her bags, threw them in the car and opened the door for Anna. I watched the way her hips bent and the beautiful curves they made as she sat in my car.

As we drove and made small talk, I felt the entire inside of the car began to glow with love. I was buzzing from it and I know Anna must have felt it as well. I could taste the attraction to each other.

Anna was going to see her parents for the holidays and told me all about how neurotic they could be and how for many years she had been upset with them but now was trying to put it behind her. I just sat there and listened to this perfect 10 and thought about how lucky I was to just spend a little time with her. I could have listened to her talk the entire time. Her voice was very high and refined and so feminine and sweet. Yet there was a subtle strength behind it. She was a girl who had overcome rejection from her family, and recently, rejection from her ex boyfriend, but had managed to rise above it. I could not help but think just how lucky they man would be whom she loved next. I was smitten.

When we got to the airport, Anna asked me to come in for awhile and wait with her. I did so and as we sat next to each other on the bench. Anna was wearing shorts and I looked at how perfectly formed her thigh was. I think she noticed I was looking at it and she slowly moved it next to my bare leg and left it against me. I began to blush. I was almost unable to talk. The touch of this young woman drowned out everything else and I sat there glowing.

Just before it was time to go, she told me how lucky she thought her best friend Suz was for having found me. And then she said she thought I was coolest person she had ever met. She blushed and without thinking I reached out and hugged her, then kissed her gently on the cheek, which prompted her to kiss me on the cheek, and we held there for just a moment too long. I pulled away first and wished her good luck with her family. She thanked me again and said she will see me when got back.

Anna became almost like part of my relationship with Suz. Anna would call Suz and sometimes just talk to me instead. We all would go out for afternoon coffee together, and sometimes Suz would ask me to do personal things for Anna like take her shopping. Many days I would be alone at Suz’s place and Anna would come over after working out at the gym. We would sit and talk for an hour until Suz got home.

Now I loved my girlfriend Suz very very much. I had no intention of ever hurting her in any way. She was the best thing to happen to me in a long long time and I knew not to mess it up. I did everything in my power to conceal my feelings for her best friend Anna, and although I sensed Anna felt the same, neither of us ever took the first step. However we flirted heavily when we were alone together.

Suz expressed how nice it was that we all could get along and hang out together. I don’t think she sensed what was going on. Suz was a fantastic girl and no one had every cheated on her or anything like that. She was oblivious to that thing and I truly wanted her not to have to worry.

One day Suz asked me if I would help Anna move because I had a truck. I pretended to be very against the idea and said no. But Suz kept asking me and I finally I gave in and told her I would do it, only cause I loved her and would do just about anything she wanted. This made her happy.

It was a very hot August Saturday morning when I arrived at Anna’s with my truck. Anna opened the door wearing pink short shorts and a cut off tank top. She looked incredible and I was speechless. She hugged me very close and whispered in my ear how grateful she was for my help. I could feel her entire body against mine and it felt like going home. It was perfect fit against mine with her breasts against my torso and her hips just below mine. She smelled so intoxicating that I became numb. Finally we stepped back and looked deeply into each others eyes.

As we began moving, I could not keep my eyes off her ass in those pink short shorts that tightly cupped her buttocks. It was all I could think about and she caught me peeking more than once. Then we began to joke around and try to trip each other while moving. When we picked up the couch, we kept trying to slam each other into the wall and were cracking up. Once I was coming down the stairs carrying a very heavy box and as Anna passed me she spanked me and teased me not to drop her precious China or else.

So, I returned the favor when I passed her on the stairs and spanked her glorious butt. My hand bounced off her ass like a basketball. She laughed and giggled and scolded me to stop titalating her in a playful way. But she one upped me the next time I passed her on the stairs by grabbing my crotch and giving me a quick squeeze. This time I froze and had to put down the box to take a breath. She laughed in a teasing way and continued up the stairs telling me to be careful.

I was so turned now at that moment, that I had to stop playing with her. I was not prepared to jeopardize my relationship with Suz, even for someone as perfect as Anna. It was not fair to Suz and I was set against it.

Anna and I spent the rest of that day moving her stuff into her new place. Suz dropped by before we were finished and we all went out for dinner. There I was, sitting with two unbelievable dream girls and in love with both of them. I felt like the luckiest man alive and was beaming.

Suz, being the amazing woman that she is, told me I had to stay and help Anna put up all her furniture and not to come home until I did even if it took all weekend. I pretended to be very annoyed by this and teased Anna at her being a slave driver. I told them I would stay the night but had other stuff to do the next day. They teased me some more and then Suz went home leaving Anna and I together again.

Anna and I worked in her new place setting it up until very late. Then she told me to stop for awhile and opened a bottle of wine for us. We both sat there in candlelight talking and sharing and laughing. We were both sweaty and tired and soon I told her it was time to go to bed and asked her where I should sleep.

Anna got up and walked over to me and began to give me a shoulder massage.

“I can’t thank you enough for helping me today. You are really an incredible man and I think Suz is the luckiest girl in the world” Anna gushed. She held me very close and then looked up at me and deep into my eyes. She kissed my cheek once, then again, then again and again. I was frozen and very confused. My instinct was to take this beautiful woman and make deep and passionate love to her. Every fiber in my being craved it. But I refused to hurt Suz in this way and held back.

Then Anna began to confess.

“I know I shouldn’t tell you this. I told myself I wouldn’t tell you this. But I simply can’t keep it a secret anymore. I am completely in love with you Zac.” She said as she stared me in the eyes while holding me. “I want to give myself to you in every possible way. I want you to have all of me and I want all of you. You are all I have been able to think about lately. I don’t know what to do about it because Suz is your girlfriend and you guys are happy and I would never want to hurt my best friend. But the feelings I have for you are so powerful, that I can no longer control them.” She said almost in tears.

I pulled Anna closer to me and held her there as she gently sobbed. Again I was aware at how perfectly out bodies matched, and how much chemistry there was between us. I was very excited by what she had just told me and my cock began to grow as the blood rushed to it quickly. Anna could feel my erection and stopped sobbing as she buried her head into my chest and drew as close to me as physically possible. I kissed her head several times as I pondered what I was about to do. Anna was the forbidden fruit, the one thing I couldn’t have. She was the switch that could destroy the wonderful relationship I had with Suz and send my world into darkness and pain. Normally, I would never even had allowed myself to be in a situation like this but Anna was different. I realized that although I was totally happy with Suz and it was wonderful and I loved her very much, the fact that I had allowed us to end up here meant that I might love Anna more. Deep down, I knew this was true.

Once that thought hit me, I forcefully tilted Anna’s head up, looked at her tear soaked eyes, and kissed her passionately. The kiss was electric sending shivers down my spine and turning off my brain. I wanted Anna. All I wanted was Anna. I wanted every inch of Anna. I wanted to crawl inside Anna and kiss her spirit within. I wanted to have children with Anna.

I picked Anna up in my arms and walked her over to the bed we had just put together. She just gawked at me the whole time. I laid her down gently and grabbed her tee shirt and slowly lifted it over her head exposing her magnificent breasts. She reached around and unhooked her bra exposing her silver dollar sized nipples which were completely erect. She grabbed my head and forced my lips to her breasts. As I began to place suction on her left nipple she let out a deep and powerful moan. This did something to my body and I had to rip my jeans off. She quickly removed my tee shirt and placed her hands on my chest.

Like hungry wolves we ripped at each others clothes until we were naked and then I rolled on top of her and began to rub my cock on her public hair. We kissed each other like we were eating each other as my cock found it’s way into her hole of love. I slowly went deep, then deeper, then as deep as I could go sending Anna’s back arching and forced her jaw to open wide as she let out a moan of ecstasy.

Anna began to cry. “Are you alright?” I asked.

“I am so happy Zac. I have dreamed about this for too long. I’ve never cried during sex Zac. This is crazy.” She said as her tears turned to laughter. “No one has every made me feel this way.”

sex stories

I gently kissed her neck as I took her hips and began to thrust into her back and forth. Her head went back again and more moaning. After awhile I tuned her over on her stomach and made love to her from behind as I watched her ass bounce as my cock moved in and out. I could not believe how incredible her ass was. I didn’t want to cum yet so right before I did, I kept switching positions. I was consumed by her. Driven by some kind of force I had never known before. She was turning me into the best lover I had ever been. The kind of sex I had only heard about and read about. I couldn’t get enough.

Anna asked me to get on top of her again and she dug her hands into my back as she began to cum all over my cock. Her spasms came like waves over her. I could no longer hold back and just as I exploded into this love queen, she had another orgasm with me. We both came together our first time.

Anna rubbed her hands all over my body and nurtured me with them. She was moaning and in a state of bliss. As I was too. It was one of the most wonderful feelings I had ever felt and if it had been any better, my body wouldn’t have been able to handle it.

We held each other as close as possible gently kissing as our spirits glowed as one.

And as we lay there and came back down from the heavens, we both began to contemplate what this meant. The ramifications of how something so wonderful to us, was absolutely destructive to us as well. We didn’t say anything, but we were both thinking it.

“Zac, I am completely in love with you. With all my being I love you. That was the most wonderful thing I have ever experienced. You are simply incredible.” Anna told me.

“Anna, I am only incredible because you make me that way.” I said.

As Anna dozed off, I got up and got dressed again and laid out a blanket on the floor and went to sleep. I was worried that Suz might stop by the next day and I didn’t want to be caught in her best friends bed.

During the night Anna had gotten up and lay down next to me cause I woke up and we were both embraced on the floor. I began to kiss her and as she came to, she let out a gigantic smile.

“Any day I wake up looking in your eyes, is a good day.” She said.

She began to kiss me and I led her naked body to the bed again and went down on her pussy. I began to lick her clit and she came all over my face. Then she began to suck my cock and placed me in the 69 position. I came inside her mouth in under 2 minutes and felt very embarrassed.

We got up and took a shower together washing every inch of each others body. We towled each other off and began to tickle each other.

“I don’t want you to leave Zac. Not ever.” Suz said.

“I feel the same way Anna.” I said.

“I’m totally in love you. You drive me crazy. When can I see you again? What are we going to tell Suz? Poor Suz. Oh god. This is torture. Maybe she will understand. Do ya think?” Anna asked.

I told Anna that this was a very special situation that needed to be handled carefully. But inside, I became painfully aware of how sad this was. Someone was going to get hurt in a very bad way. And neither one of them deserved that. I was too afraid to face that so I thought that perhaps what Anna and I had together was a giant flame that might burn out eventually. To be honest, I thought Anna was out of my league and might just be really lonely. Perhaps I was just a phase for her and a way to heal from her previous bad relationships. In that light, I felt maybe what I was doing was actually a good thing. Suz would want her best friend to heal and find love. But of course with anyone other than me, her boyfriend.

Just then, Suz called Anna and asked how we were doing. Of course Anna lied and told her that I was bothering her and she would be sending me back to her first thing.

After she hung up, she looked at me and said, “This is going to be difficult. I don’t want to lie to Suz, I don’t want to hurt her, or lose her. And I don’t want to lose you either. It has taken my entire life just to find you. And I can’t stand the thought of sharing you either. Oh no. I can’t stand the thought of you having sex with another woman now. Anna said and sat down and buried her head in her hands.

Just last year I was lonely and miserable and thought I would never find love. And now, I had to choose between two of the most amazing women I had ever met. How did I get here? Life is sometimes like that. Filled with wonderment right next to tragedy.

I consoled Anna and reassured her not to worry and that a solution would present itself. But you know, the forbidden fruit is forbidden for a reason and I sank into sadness as I drove over to my girlfriend Suz and thought about all the wonderful times we have had and how she brought me back to life and turned my life into the bright side of the road.

I looked deeply into my feelings to find some answers. What did I want? I wanted Anna. Anna and I had a connection that Suz and I did not. Anna and I had incredible sex and more passion than a man can stand. Anna needed me. And although Suz was drop dead gorgeous, Anna was better. Anna has had a sense of loss in her life and worked through it. Suz has always had a wonderful life and probably always will.

So, I wanted Anna. But I didn’t want to lose Suz either, and definitely didn’t want to hurt her.

Before I saw Suz again, I called up Anna and she picked up the phone in tears.

“Anna, I don’t want you to worry. I am madly in love with you and you are the only woman I want. I can’t have sex with Suz again after what you and I just shared. But you must have a little patience with us if we are to keep from hurting Suz ok?”

Anna agreed. I had no idea what to do, but I knew what I wanted. I wanted Anna.

When I saw Suz again, she seemed a little distant. Like she sensed something had happened or something. I was very strange. That next night I lay down next to her and she was very cold. I wondered if she knew and Anna had told her.

Then the next day, Suz went to work and left me in her apartment. Then Anna called.

“YOu are never going to believe this she said. Are you sitting down?” Anna said very excited. “Suz wanted you to stay with me last night because she has fallen in love with someone else. She told me all about it just a second ago. She had him over for dinner last night and they made out. They didn’t have sex but they wanted to. Suz was a mess wondering what to do about it because she didn’t want to hurt you. “

I was stunned at this. All kinds of feelings rushed though me and it was difficult to focus on one.

“What should I tell her Zac?” Anna asked.

I composed myself and said, “Tell her that she should tell me the truth and that I can handle it and that’s it;s better to be honest about it than to lie. Tell her that I had confessed to you yesterday that I was feeling stagnant in our relationship and was thinking about taking a break.” I said.

“What about us? I mean, I have to see you now and console you. I have to spend the night with you Zac. You are all I can think about you know that? I am madly in love with you. I can’t believe that a doorway has opened for us to be together.” Anna said beaming. “I love you and I’ll call you back ok?”

Anna called back an hour later and said that Suz didn’t feel that she could tell me and asked that Anna tell me instead. I found that rather shitty but kinda understood.

“So Zac, come over now because I have something to tell you. And something else to give you. Come now!” She said.

I arrived at Anna’s and was mauled by her naked body as she ripped off my clothes and I fucked her standing up in the hallway, then we lay on the kitchen table, then we fell to the floor and made love there, then to the bed and made love for hours until we exhausted ourselves.

“Well, I hope that takes the sting out of your girlfriend breaking up with you.” Anna said as we both laughed together until we cried.

“I better call Suz now.” I said.

When Suz picked up the phone, she was very nervous.

“Suz, Anna told me that you have fallen in love with someone else. What can I say? I want you to know how much I have loved you and enjoyed being with you and I want to thank you for all you have done for me. I am a little sad that things between us are over because we had such a good relationship but I have been thinking about taking a break myself lately and didn’t know how to tell you. So really, everything is fine, I totally understand, and am not upset. In fact, I want you to be happy even if it’s not with me. I hope we can stay in touch and I have a feeling we will become good friends.”

Suz was blown away by this and thanked me over and over for understanding and being so cool. Meanwhile Anna was giving me a strip tease.

Well, this is my sex story about bitting into the forbidden fruit and how I fell in love with my girlfriend’s best friend. I was very lucky 3 times. Lucky to have met Suz, lucky to have met Anna, and lucky to have been able to be with Anna without any drama. Most of my life I have had terrible luck, but it all fell on me when I really needed it.

It’s been 6 months now and I am more in Love with Anna than ever. I have asked her to marry me and she said yes. Suz is thrilled that we hooked up and is our closest friend. After all, she introduced us. And Suz is still with the man she fell in love with.

I don’t know if everyone should eat the forbidden fruit. But if you do, then perhaps there is a reason why that you should pay attention to.

May you love and be loved.

ZAC

“